Simez said:
@ JustOnes
I know we've been going back and forth in another thread, but I'm not going to get into any of that to shit up this thread.
Re: PSP/PS2 versions
Anything Wii version does is replicated with the analogue stick, apart from the flashlight. The developers really catered to the one analogue stick concept and made the game really comfortable in your hands. This game does the psych tests, gets to know you and then changes the game around to fuck with your mind. Besides the graphics this game does not feel diluted in any way. Climax really and truly care about their game and the Silent Hill universe, Double Helix (SH:Homecoming) need to step down.
I'm not going to into Yamaoka with you
I can say before team Silent left he was only a musician. Others can keep the game aesthetics feeling like a Silent Hill game, but what I'm worried about, is whether they can keep the game sounding like a Silent Hill game.
Konami have other musicians at hand sure but Akira Yamaoka is truly one of a kind.
The motion control went much further than the flashlight, though. It was used for running, crawling, swimming, looking around in first-person, etc. Is the flashlight just fixed in place, or what?
I guess they could squeak by without motion control. I think the experience as a whole takes a hefty hit, though.
I liked Homecoming. There's a lot of fan beef with it, but I liked it a lot, other than the storyline was basically just lifted from Silent Hill 2.
Yamaoka wasn't just the composer, though. He was the creative supervisor and series director. And even if he wasn't, these games start with the music, they're built around the music, which is why he was promoted to series director to begin with. They can probably get a good composer, but I don't know what they'll do with creative director. To be honest, I wouldn't be surprised if they handed one or both jobs to Mary Elizabeth McGlynn; she's already been promoted to voice direction and next to Yamaoka has been there for more games in the series than anyone else.
So basically, they can nail the atmosphere. It's the sound and plot development I'm worried about.
But hey, some have brought up that while Yamaoka has severed his contract with Konami, there's nothing to stop him from working on the series as an independant contractor, so he might not even be gone, lol.
( Edited 27.01.2010 19:44 by justonesp00lturn )
NNID: crackedthesky
My blog, mostly about writing:
http://www.davidjlovato.com