The analogues on this new pad are in the exact same place (never got why the lower left stick bothered anyone), and what's so uncomfortable about the shoulders? I also prefer the 360 controller's shape, and definitely the triggers (keepin' the Dreamcast alive!), but it has it's own shortcomings. People always mention the 360 d-pad as being shit, and that's maybe a fair point, but no-one ever seems to mention the worst buttons in the world - the 360 pad's shoulder buttons! Clicky and unresponsive as fuck. Really crap buttons.
Go try it - pick up your 360 controller and just have a goose on those shoulder buttons - they're rubbish! Really cheap and nasty. I've had three 360 pads of my own (one went back with the RRoD 360), and have played many others. I notice it on all of them. The PlayStation pad may have more of a retro shape, but there's no crap build-quality on it anywhere. It's a consistent and excellent pad, it's just a bit old school, maybe.
I'm saying it's really lulzy just how far some people will complain about the PlayStation pad, as if it actually hurts your hand! Come on, now! Did you not play and completely bum the PSone and PS2? I did. Never had any problems then, still don't now. It's a bit old school, like I said, but on the other hand it's a nice familiar shape, too. I find that the controller doesn't so much 'fit my hand', but my hand 'fits the controller' due to sheer muscle-memory alone.
I've played far too much PlayStation in my time to have ever had a problem with the controller. The GC pad wasn't perfect. It had a shape to die for, but the button-spalcement was like a Tonka Toy. Big A button was nice (I really liked that button), the B button was alright, wasn't offending anyone. I found the X and Y buttons to be in funny places, and when using the X button in particular I'll often unintentionally mash the A button.
The triggers seemed rather vague, to me (in comparison to the excellent Dreamcast/Xbox triggers), the d-pad was too-minuscule for me, and while I liked the sticks, I wasn't too sure about them being different sizes. Might be perfect if you have a really hench left hand, and a really withered and tiny right hand (Jeremy Beadle?). The action on them (how 'resistant' they are to move) was absolutely spot-on, though. The saving grace. The Z button on the GC pad might be the worst bit of button-placement ever.
In general, I also just found the design of it a bit too 'out there' for it's own good. I played a couple games on my GameCube that were clearly hampered by an overall lack of buttons. Obviously Street Fighter was a complete no-go, but I'm not even talking about that. Some big multi-platform games had to combine buttons and stuff for certain actions on the GC version, purely because there wasn't enough buttons.
So yeah, the 360 and GC pads have faults of their own.
( Edited 27.01.2010 23:28 by Martin_ )