E308 | Wii Music 'Better Than a Video Game', Says Miyamoto

By Adam Riley 19.07.2008 28

Sadly Nintendo's demonstration of Wii Music on-stage at this year's E3 event probably put a lot of people off the game, but Miyamoto-san believes it will appeal to a wider audience thanks to it being more of a musical toy that will make it "...better than a video game."

From the reception on the show floor it became clear that the cacophony produced during the group demonstration hardly did anything to sell the idea of Wii Music, unlike the successful trialling of Wii Fit the year prior. However, reports state that the individual play-tests were far better, with players able to get a better feel of the instruments on offer, such as the guitars, steel drums, vibraphones, harpsichords, toy pianos, singers, tubas and even dog suits. Of course, being able to re-arrange the classic Super Mario Bros. started to win gamers over as well. Add in that the player's Mii character can 'Beat Box' and suddenly the whole prospect becomes slightly more interesting.

Shigeru Miyamoto actually believes Wii Music can act as some sort of educational tool that will appeal to those not quite enamoured with Rock Band and Guitar Hero, stating:

"I really think that half of an elementary music school could be dedicated to this. I'm hoping that through Wii Music, we'll get more drummers, more musicians and more people interested in music."

Is Wii Music something that has your ear pricked up so far, or will you be likely to steer clear when it finally launches later this year?

Box art for Wii Music
Developer

Nintendo

Publisher

Nintendo

Genre

Rhythm

Players

4

C3 Score

Rated $score out of 10  7/10

Reader Score

Rated $score out of 10  5/10 (22 Votes)

European release date Out now   North America release date Out now   Japan release date Out now   Australian release date Out now   

Comment on this article

You can comment as a guest or join the Cubed3 community below: Sign Up for Free Account Login

Preview PostPreview Post Your Name:
Validate your comment
  Enter the letters in the image to validate your comment.
Submit Post

Comments

I have to admit the game is interesting..but not something i want to pay my hard-earned money for. And I dont even have a balance board, and i play the drums, so i guess ill just play the real drums.

If u want to unite core and casual players atleast implment objectives and career modes into the wii franchises. They could be the secondary option in the games that the core can acces whilst the casual can jump straight to the single play mode without confusion. Difficulty has to exist what happened to the age old difficulty settings. Games could be set on easy for the casual and the core could easy go to settings and change this. It seems nintendo just cater to the casual in regards to the wii sport/ music franchises and hope the core will play.

Guest 19.07.2008#3

Better than a videogame? Holy crap, sign me up!

I stick by my view that you can buy any Warioware game and get most of the stuff in Wii music for free as well as loads of crazy fun mini-games.

Warioware souveniers > Wii Music. And cheaper too.

( Edited 19.07.2008 17:02 by SuperLink )

Twitter | C3 Writer/Moderator | Backloggery

Wish I could get the full sentence/sentences of what he said somewhere. It's annoying when places like Kotaku make a several paragraph article out of a quote they seemingly cherry picked.

Guest 19.07.2008#6

He probably meant it in 'Better than just your standard video game'.

Didn't he just say it as a tongue-in-cheek answer at somebody's smart arse question about it being too simple or something similar?

"Sadly Nintendo's demonstration of Wii Music on-stage at this year's E3 event probably put a lot of people off the game, but Miyamoto-san believes it will appeal to a wider audience thanks to it being more of a musical toy that will make it "...better than a video game." "


I have no interest in this game what so ever. The stage demo was one of the worst moments I have ever witnessed on a E3 stage, seriously. That's saying something when you consider this is the same man that walked on stage with a plastic sword and shield and made a whole auditorium cheer with delight as a result. It's not often I rubbish Miyamoto's claims but this is one time I can easily. This is nothing more than a shallow toy, fuck this crap and give me Rock!, Band 2.

Guest 19.07.2008#9

However, in an interview at E3 2008, Miyamoto was fielding questions from the crowd and remarked that Wii Music is even better than a video game - it is a musical toy!

Miyamoto based his view on the fact that the game has no over-arching goal to it, no objectives to complete and no content to unlock or progress through. Instead, what it does have is a lot of music-making potential and a free reign to have a bash at making a melody.

\"And that\'s why it\'s better than a video game,\" said Miyamoto.

found this at....wait for the edit.

edit; http://www.bit-tech.net/news/2008/07/18/miyamoto-wii-music-is-better-than-a-game/1

( Edited 19.07.2008 17:59 by Bart.... )

Demoni Rakkausenkeli said:
I have to admit the game is interesting..but not something i want to pay my hard-earned money for. And I dont even have a balance board, and i play the drums, so i guess ill just play the real drums.

My thoughts exactly.

It's not a game at all to me. Even playground games and board games have things like objectives and/or winners. This is indeed a toy... and an expensive toy at that. I was really hoping this was going to be a lot cooler.

Its actualy more a muscial re-arrangement software then anything else.
You cant "play" anything, but you can adjust musicial features in different instruments.

This isnt such a bad thing, imho.
Especialy the ability to send the "mix" to friends, and make simple music videos.

Theres nothing wrong with electronic toys rather then having objectives.
Bezires, its not that it costs Nintendo much resources to do this stuff.

http://www.fanficmaker.com <-- Tells some truly terrible tales.
Last update; Mice,Plumbers,Animatronics and Airbenders. We also have the socials; Facebook & G+

we\'ll get more drummers, more musicians and more people interested in music.\"

Drummers and musicians aren\'t one in the sameSmilie

( Edited 19.07.2008 21:02 by TAG )

TAG: That American Guy

"If it is possible, as far as it depends on you, live at peace with everyone." Romans 12:18
Guest 20.07.2008#14

TAG said:
we'll get more drummers, more musicians and more people interested in music."

Drummers and musicians aren't one in the sameSmilie

He actually makes a clear distinction between people, musicians and drummers, although I think I qualify for all three.

I really can\'t see this going down well with casual gamers like my parents or somthing I actually think they would be offended.
The concept sounds like a 3-5 year olds fisher price interactive toy.

( Edited 20.07.2008 02:02 by Blade2t3 )

Educational...in the sense that it'll interest more people to music? That's not educational Smilie

Blade2t3 said:
I really can't see this going down well with casual gamers like my parents or somthing I actually think they would be offended.
The concept sounds like a 3-5 year olds fisher price interactive toy.


Exactly, casual gamer does not mean unable to grasp the concept of actual gameplay. Smilie
If I told my family about a game where you push 2 buttons in an alternating fashion to make sound come out they'd think it was retarded. If by some miracle they didn't all I'd have to do is show them that E3 performance...

Wii Music will be shit.

That is all. Smilie

Tom Barry [ Reviewer - Editor - Resident Sim-Racer @ Cubed3.com ] 

Well I can definitely see this as something to promote music but it is way to simplistic. So disappointed.

Its better than sex

Guest 20.07.2008#21

iCAME said:
Its better than sex

And cleaner as well. And safer. (if you remember to strap the wiimote to your wrist of course)

Colour me amused.

I think Miyamato must be going senile or have Mad Cow Disease or something.

I'd get this game. If I was 3 years old that is.

Wii Music looked awful at E3. Great idea, but in practice it's just lame. The Wiimote/balance board controls are clearly pretty wishy-washy, since that professional drummer couldn't even keep a beat with them (so how is a non-drummer going to?), and the other instruments were just a joke. The software automatically plays notes in-key, so all you really have to is just spam the buttons and flail the 'mote around to 'play it'.

It sounded like crap, too.

Wii Sports is going to be crap too. Really, if I want to play tennis I'd just go outside and play the real thing. If I want to box, I'll just beat up on my little brother. No one will want to pay money for it.

Wii Fit is going to be crap. If I want to do yoga I can just pull my mat out and do it. I don't need to spend my cash on this 'game' and a balance board. Nintendo must have mad cow disease.

Wii Music will look awful and sound like crap too. I think Nintendo has suddenly lost it. What were they thinking?

Look unto me in every thought. Doubt not. Fear not.

Subscribe to this topic Subscribe to this topic

If you are a registered member and logged in, you can also subscribe to topics by email.
Sign up today for blogs, games collections, reader reviews and much more
Site Feed
Who's Online?
jb

There are 1 members online at the moment.