I\'ve played quite a bit more now and I\'m pretty impressed with the main games.
The sword fighting is incredibly accurate and strategy seems to play a big part in the 1 on 1 fights and the showdown mode (where you basically work your way across a certain terrain of the island slicing various degrees of opponents) - there\'s another mode of which the name escapes me where you basically have to slice objects in the right motion faster than your opponent - playing the computer at this stage is quite fun (I suspect as you level up it gets much harder) but multiplayer wise I think that could be seriously addictive!
The ping-pong is really great and probably the most impressive of the lot. I was a bit dismayed through the first few games because the game didn\'t seem to be picking up all of my swings, it seemed to have a lot of trouble with delayed forehand shots. Then I realized I was in tennis mode; once you grasp that this game is played with your wrist, WM+ seems to pick up really subtle movements. I love how easy it is to put spin on the ball and really effect your placement in a way that was never possible in tennis on Wii Sports.
Archery is the last of what I would say is the big three. This mode, by far, feels the most satisfying and impressive. The way you actually emulate a real bow and arrow; aiming with the wii-mote, pulling Z, drawing back the nun chuck and releasing to fire - it does convince you that you\'re actually doing it. The various courses range in difficulty and while there\'s nothing massively complex about the game itself - I\'m convinced this one of the games you\'ll come back to.
Frisbee, power-cruising, wakeboarding and basketball I\'d say are in the second bracket in terms of quality. Different people will like some more than others here. The basketball was impressive initially - the actual shooting method especially. But from what I\'ve seen of the modes, there\'s not enough depth or difficulty. Snatching the ball in 3 on 3 is too easy, and the lack of deliberate player movement (unlike in say tennis on Wii Sports) is hard to put up with and not incorporated very well. The power-cruising and wakeboarding are two games that feels great but will probably get a little dull after while. The wave physics are impressive, and both feel pretty damn good, but there\'s not much substance beyond either. There are various simple courses in the power-cruising, and wakeboarding doesn\'t have much beyond random tricks and battles to keep you occupied. The best of these games in my opinion is frisbee, which showcases WM+ well through how it picks up subtle movements. A word to the wise, don\'t get carried away and launch your wii-mote especially if you\'re one of those people who insist you or your friends will never be stupid enough to require wrist straps. This one has a good range of modes and arguably, could be in the top bracket for some.
Golf is the most controversial choice of my lowest ranking group. Though many have complained that its too easy to put spin on everything, and its too sensitive, I haven\'t really had these problems. As long as you learn not to be very aggressive in your swings, and really focus on swinging properly - I think this game is a big improvement over the original, especially when it comes to putting. The reason its down here amidst the lowest ranking games is because I\'m bored of this title. They should have improved other aspects, instead all they did was apply this new technology and slap together a few unimaginative resort island courses.
The other stragglers; air sports are really quite fun but there\'s absolutely no longevity in them, canoeing was never a fun sport in the first place and cycling is just questionable - it works quite well, but its not fun, I get the sense Nintendo were looking for one last sport to shove in there and they just figured they\'d take the handlebar ergonomics of power-cruising and put it on land. The course I did was exactly the same as the longest jogging course on Wii Fit, just so you know. I do like the whole island theme that\'s stretching across this series of active Nintendo games.
Overall, I\'d say it\'s a pretty damn great package. It\'s definitely one of the best Wii games to come along for quite a long time, its got a lot of content, the big hitters are addictive and will last as long as Wii Sports has if not longer, and it showcases the possibilities of Wii Motion Plus expertly. Whether its worth £40 is another matter.
Thinking in terms of equivalents - the original Wii Sports showed off the original capabilities of the console and it was pretty good fun. This shows off the capabilities of WM+ and it\'s also pretty good fun. But its also not free, so therefore you might expect this offering to a bit more content heavy. The original was four solid games that all had longevity, subtract the less impressive games in resort and its exactly the same (I\'m promoting frisbee for the sake of my argument) - in which case £40 is probably a little much. Some maybe would rather have got a cut down version for £20.
Ultimately I guess the thing you have to consider is that this also comes with a piece of tech which seems to be selling for £15/£20 on its own anyway. On that basis - this is an excellent package. If you think you\'re just paying for the game, then it\'s a little bit over-priced in my opinion, but still worth it (because there aren\'t that many great Wii games around right now).
Edit: Forgot to say, this game clearly wins in multiplayer mode. Therefore perhaps I\'d expect more people to feel more inclinced once they\'ve picked up an extra WM+ from another game. The question is, how long will that take?
( Edited 23.07.2009 17:29 by TheStratMan )